Surviving 27 Outs: No-Hitter Edition
Recently I wrote an out-by-out survival analysis of throwing a perfect game. Now, let’s discuss baseball’s next biggest achievement: the no-hitter. Like the perfect game, a no-hitter has a simple definition that adds to the prestige of it: pitch a complete game and win without giving up a hit. Because perfect games require no baserunners at all, both in and out of a pitcher’s control, they are much rarer than a no-hitter. Still, there haven’t been many.
I used the same perfect game dataset from 1920-2025 of 379,815
starts. We are looking at the survival analysis of pitchers who started the
game, so combined no-hitters are excluded. By MLB’s definition, a no-hitter has
to be at least 27 outs and result in a win. That leaves us with 216 no-hitters
since 1920.
Like last time, my attention immediately points towards the
fact that 0.057% of starts are no-hitters (216/379,815), but 0.058% are hitless
through 27 outs. That’s because despite there being 216 no-hitters, there have
been 222 starts hitless through 9 innings. We already know about Harvey Haddix
and Pedro Martinez’s special starts that were perfect through 9 innings. What
were the other four?
- Bobo Newsom on September 18, 1934 lost his no-hitter in the 10th inning, when a single after two walks gave up the winning run to make Newsom the losing pitcher.
- Jim Maloney on June 14, 1965 was hitless through 10 innings before giving up a home run to lead off the 11th inning. He completed the 11th inning but ultimately lost the game. I think what’s most impressive about Maloney is in another start in 1965, on August 19, he pitched a 10-inning no-hitter—the only 10-inning no-hitter in my dataset.
- On July 26, 1991, Mark Gardner was hitless through 9 before giving up a lead-off hit in the 10th inning.
- Rich Hill on August 23, 2017 was not just hitless, but perfect through 8 innings before an error broke it to lead off the 9th inning. After completing the 9th inning, Hill gave up a walk-off home run to lead off the 10th inning to lose the game.
There have been 55 games where pitchers were hitless through
26 but unable to complete the no-hitter. Recent examples include Yoshinobu
Yamamoto in 2025, Framber Valdez in 2024, and Alex Cobb in 2023.


Comments
Post a Comment